Sitaare Zameen Par Movie Review: Aamir Khan's Well-Intentioned but Preachy Spiritual Sequel
Sixteen years after Taare Zameen Par (2007) redefined inclusive storytelling in Bollywood, Aamir Khan returns with Sitaare Zameen Par, a spiritual sequel that swaps dyslexia for neurodivergence. Directed by RS Prasanna (Shubh Mangal Saavdhan) and adapted from the Spanish film Campeones, this 2024 release aims to educate and entertain—but does it strike the right balance? Here’s our deep dive.
Sitaare Zameen Par: At a Glance
The Premise
Gulshan (Aamir Khan), a hot-headed basketball coach, is sentenced to community service after a drunk-driving incident. His punishment? Training a team of neurodivergent players with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and Down Syndrome. What begins as a clash of egos evolves into a journey of empathy—but not without heavy-handed life lessons.
1. Neurodivergence in Bollywood: Progress or Stereotype?
The Good
- Representation: Features actors with real developmental disabilities, a rarity in Hindi cinema.
- Self-Aware Humor: Moments like Sharmaji’s (Rishi Sahani) quip "Naya coach gadha hai" land well.
- Social Message: Challenges the use of words like "pagal" (mad) to describe neurodivergent individuals.
The Flaws
- Inspiration Porn: Characters often exist to teach Gulshan (and the audience) rather than as fully realized people.
- Limited Backstories: Unlike Ishaan in Taare Zameen Par, most players get superficial treatment.
- Positive Stereotyping: Their perpetual cheerfulness avoids the messy reality of neurodivergent lives.
"By painting these characters as ungrudging inspirations, does the film truly advocate inclusion or just dilute complexity?"
2. Aamir Khan’s Gulshan: Redemption Arc or Preachy Protagonist?
The Character
Gulshan is classic Aamir Khan territory—a flawed man who transforms through exposure to societal issues. His journey from arrogance ("Pagal") to advocacy follows a predictable but effective arc.
The Meta Critique
In a standout scene, player Satbir (Aroush Datta) shouts, "Sir, pehle aap chup rahiye!" (Sir, first you shut up!) during a game. It’s a wry nod to Khan’s own reputation for didactic storytelling.
Performance Highlights
- Physical Comedy: Khan’s height jokes (a recurring gag) add levity.
- Emotional Beats: His breakdown after realizing his biases feels genuine.
- The Halo Effect: Like Nikumbh in Taare Zameen Par, Gulshan becomes a moral compass—sometimes to the film’s detriment.
3. Sitaare vs. Taare Zameen Par: How Do They Compare?
| Aspect | Taare Zameen Par (2007) | Sitaare Zameen Par (2024) |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Dyslexia in children | Neurodivergence in adults |
| Lead Performance | Aamir as mentor Nikumbh | Aamir as flawed student Gulshan |
| Emotional Depth | Ishaans loneliness drove the narrative | Team’s struggles are underdeveloped |
| Subtlety | Show, don’t tell | Over-explained messages |
Verdict: While Sitaare broadens representation, it lacks the organic emotional punch of its predecessor.
4. RS Prasanna’s Direction: Hits and Misses
Strengths
- Accessible Tone: Balances heavy themes with humor (e.g., the team mocking Gulshan).
- Delhi Setting: Authentic middle-class milieu with Genelia D’Souza as Gulshan’s wife.
- Basketball Sequences: Well-choreographed, though overly focused on Gulshan’s perspective.
Weaknesses
- Montage Overload: Character backstories are rushed via sentimental montages.
- Nostalgia Bait: Forced callbacks to Taare Zameen Par songs ("Bum Bum Bole").
- Simplified Conflict: Villains (like Gulshan’s boss) are cartoonishly evil.
5. Final Verdict: Should You Watch Sitaare Zameen Par?
The Pros
- Important representation of neurodivergent adults
- Aamir Khan’s committed performance
- Moments of genuine humor and warmth
The Cons
- Overly preachy tone
- Underwritten supporting characters
- Lacks the nuance of Taare Zameen Par
"Sitaare Zameen Par means well but forgets that neurodivergent stories deserve more than just being teachable moments."
Sitaare Zameen Par: FAQs
Is Sitaare Zameen Par a sequel to Taare Zameen Par?
No. It’s a spiritual successor with similar themes but no narrative connection.
Is the movie based on a true story?
No. It’s a remake of Spain’s Campeones (2018), which was inspired by real basketball teams for people with disabilities.
Does Aamir Khan sing in this film?
No new songs, but the soundtrack includes nostalgic tracks from his older films.
Comments
Post a Comment